Paw-Prints of the Gods- Steph Bennion
Paw-Prints is a pretty solid standalone,
but for all that I regret not reading Hollow Moon first. I would have preferred
a full prologue, rather than the sometimes rather clunky slotting in of backstory
when the author felt it necessary. However, when strong prologue is so frowned
on by so many 'modern writing experts' its often avoidance is only to be
expected. The problem is that gradual past history integration requires very a
great deal of the writer, far more than the ability to tell a good story or
write entertainingly. This is an excellent book, don't think for a minute that
it isn't, but sometimes the simplest way of doing things is actually the best.
This is a book suited to a young teenage
audience, and so equally to everyone who doesn't require more adult content. I
very much enjoyed the book from well the wrong side of fifty. Good story telling
is good story telling.
The book was published in 2013, yet partly
through naive space science and partly through some strange cultural insensitivity
I felt I was ready a book written in the 1950's. Phrases like, "she spoke
with a sweeter Asian twist" can't really be construed as offensive, but
they certainly demonstrate a degree of cultural heavy footedness. The quirky
science is no problem at all. It is nothing to the ridiculous lack of realism
displayed by so many 'paranormal' writers. It's just a bit more Michael Crichton
than Arthur C. Clarke.
My biggest criticism is reserved for
excessive use of the single character pointers for certain of the main characters.
One of characters can't be mentioned without some reference to the game of
cricket, and another to excessive food consumption. Yet other important
characters disappear into a fog as they are left so bewilderingly thin of
detail. I'm sure this was in part the casualty of the lack a nice thick backstory
before launching into this second in series. An index list of characters might
have made the book better, and saved using such repetitive memory joggers.
Bennion is a very competent writer, who I'm
sure has plenty more adventures for Ravana lined up. Ravana is very much in the
fashion of strong female characters, but is made to feel all the more real for
lacking many of the 'superior to men' superpowers that so many 'fictional kick-arse-feminista'
possess. We seemed to be swamped by beautiful female characters that weigh less
than a bag of potatoes yet fight in a way that makes James Bond look like a
pussy. Ravana is a tough cookie, but one that mere mortals can relate to.
I think this storyline could be made into a
really good screenplay for all sorts of live film and or animation. The chances
of that happening may be nil, as media producers are swamped with brilliant
material from independent writers as it is, but that doesn't mean one shouldn't
advance the idea. There is a touch of humour in this book that I think would
work really well.
I hope that all the British rather than
American cultural references don't put off young American readers. I very much
enjoyed their presence, particularly as so too many non-American English writers
try over-hard to appeal to the American market. I know absolutely zilch about
Bennion's background, but as an aside to the plot I enjoyed speculating. I
would be very disappointed if I found out that she hasn't played cricket.
To conclude, this is a great read for the
young of all ages.
Commentaires
Enregistrer un commentaire